DreDaze wrote in post #15687590
how often are you using grad ND filters? I'd go wider if you're fine with losing 16-24mm, but that's where you were at before.
you don't 'need' to go wider...but you clearly want to...just do it...it won't hurt
oh wait, we were supposed to talk you out of the 8-16mm?
how often are you using grad ND filters? I'd go wider if you're fine with losing 16-24mm, but that's where you were at before.
you don't 'need' to go wider...but you clearly want to...just do it...it won't hurt

oh wait, we were supposed to talk you out of the 8-16mm?

I agree, seems like you want the 8-16mm! I'd say go for it - sorry can't/won't talk you out of it.
I'd go Sigma (10-20) over the Canon 10-22. It is cheaper and is close to the Canon in performance (yes the Canon is better but not by much). Plus with a 1.4X TC the Sigma can be used on a FF camera for the entire range (no modification to the lens) with little to no vignetting.

