Dan Kearley wrote in post #16353800
Has anyone done this before? I find the focus inconsistent on my copy.
(and I've have a couple copies... I kept the best one)
I expect focusing at 1.4 to be always problematic, but I find even stopped down, I have inconsistent focusing.. (both front and back)
It's going to be about 100$ to have Sigma do this... I'd love any input!
Many of us have a love/hate relationship with this lens. I assume you have the EX DC HSM version, not the newer version without the EX in the name. There were a number of QC issues with this lens related to focus. Many seem to back or front focus. My first copy was decentered and sent back to B&H. The second copy back focused a bit so I brought my lens and camera, a 60D, to Sigma's US headquarters in Ronkonkama, NY an hours drive from my home. They fixed it for me while I waited. However, the focus algorithms Sigma uses are still problematic. Sometimes the lens focuses dead on, sometimes not. I have discovered after a significant amount of testing and pixel peeping that getting accurate focus on very small targets can be difficult, especially in low light. The more contrast the subject has, the more accurate the AF. The more edges and texture the subject has, the more accurate the AF. I find this problem to be at its worse at f/1.4, and as you stop down the problem gets less frequent. The lens also tends to be softer at the edges the wider you open the aperture. These are some of the reasons this lens was just replaced by Sigma. However, to paraphrase the nursery rhyme, "When it's good, its very very good, and when it bad it horrid" For me, it is more often very good than horrid. Here are a few good examples, IMHO.
Northern Vermont

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/9229017002/
Boyden Winery, Vt, June 2013 Another view
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr
Smithsonian Air and Space Museum
IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/8498960263/
13-02-23 Smithsonian DC3
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr
Smithsonian Air and Space Museum - 100% crop
IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/8498958839/
13-02-23 Smithsonian DC3 100%
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr
Smithsonian Air and Space Museum Apollo hatch cover taken through thick glass display window
IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/8505040248/
Apollo 11 Hatch- Smithsonian - Sigma 30 mm
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr
Smithsonian Air and Space Museum - 100% crop of right side of Apollo hatch cover
IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/8503932341/
Apollo 11 Hatch- Smithsonian - Sigma 30 mm 100%
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr
Metropolitan Museum of Art, NYC
IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/75627613@N05/9474381206/
13-05-16- Metropolitan Museum of Art-14
by
mwsilver
, on Flickr