...*seller on craigslist that claims has a brand new body with receipt and all but that doesn't mean shutter hasn't been actuated a few thousands times.
This being the case, the thousand actuations, it should not be referred to as new. It isn't even a refurb since it hasn't been checked by a knowledgeable individual. All this should be refleced in the price. Egen in like new condition I would not pay more than about 75% of refurb price. You may not have any warranty, which refurbs have. Can you determine if it is grey market product.
Craiglist = buyer beware.