C&C needed on Before and after model shoot..

Ok.. I'm not sure if i'm breaking moral boundaries with this edit...

Can you just have a look and let me know what you think?? cheers guys...

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/gif' | Redirected to error image by FLICKR

I prefer the first one Trevor

I prefer #1 but both are acceptable based on what you are trying to produce.

I like what you've done to her skin highlights and shadows in the second, it less of a flash look, not the the original was over the top in that reagard.

wait...did you thin out her face? Puppet Warp?

01Ryan10 wrote in post #16585233
wait...did you thin out her face? Puppet Warp?

yes, using liquify

You did a great job on thinning her face. I like #2

The jawline on #2 looks too 'sharp', not natural to my eyes. Almost looks like she's wearing a mask. I like what you did to the rest of the image though.

Her chin on the "after" looks very unnatural.

I like #1, face look more natural. Everything else is great but her legs are kinda throwing me off. One thinner than the other. I know it's because of her pose. Great shot otherwise.

Randy

#1 like how it stands out with the DOF.

#2 i great... the chin is good, post processing good, colour tone, I'd maybe take it down a notch, but if the series is all shot in this tone, then all good..

since you started liquefying her face...you should also liquefy her figure so it would match her slimmer face.

I think # 2 looks completely unnatural and does a disservice to her. I realize it's the hot fad but I don't care for the hazy processing quality.

I prefer the colors/tones of #1.

Those saying #2 doesn't look natural, they're right when you compare the two. If they never saw #1 they'd have no point of reference and would have never mentioned it.