Robert_Lay wrote:
In my mind, making a good/bad profile and calibrating the monitor are one and the same thing - it's just a question of whether or not it works - so, in that sense the calibration can cause the problem. The mystery would be, why does it only affect his B&W work, and not his color work?
quite possibly because the tonality of B&W is so important to the image that this is the first time its noticed.
When working at the lab, we would make custom profiles for a machine, and anything with gradients is where the profiles would fail if they were incorrect.
I suggest doing a perfict black and white gradient strip in photoshop (lets say 2in x 24) and then run the posterize filter over it with 25 steps, giving you a 25step greyscale. If you see that two or more of these steps are the same tone, theres something funny with your monitor. If you see it in the gradient before the posterize feature, thtats a more clear sign there's something wrong.
but, usually this shoes up in B&W because if the tonality importance over color, and in sunsets with bright gradients.