djphotosyd wrote in post #16979385
I have to say this and the other advice you have recieved so far is spot on... and surprisingly realistic for a forum where repondents usually thing it's all about " Their Reputation" and how they want their work to look.
I did a lot of commercial work and faced the same sitiuation I think you are getting at many times. Often teh person commissioning the work was appointed the job of getting something photographed and dosen't have the first idea about it. they will tell you they want this or that and you know straight off it's going to be a dogs breakfast. Sometimes out of pride or whatever they will pretty much insist you do it the way they want.
What I used to do is firstly try to work out the details such as where the shoot would take place. I'd then recce it if I didn't know it already. From there I would suggest the actual place the photography would be done ( such as the exact spot in a park) or tell them that the location was no good and suggest an alternative or at least the requirements for somewhere suitable.
This goes for all aspects. They may plan for something to be photographed at Midday which could be the worst time for that subject. It may be a time when the light is on a building the wrong way and casting shadows or the background is inappropriate or whatever. I would advise them of my concerns and if they were insistant I would put them in writing so I had a fall back. Do not underestimate the level of turncoating and denial that goes on in corporate jungles. Some people will do and say anything to deflect blame. I found that out the hard way, even recently when I forgot the lesson.
Wherever possible, I would ask with as much insistance as was polite to do it their way and to do what I thought was best. I would add that if they did not want what I did, they would not be charged. IF they liked my idea, obviously they paid for the time in doing it their way ( the wrong way! :0) ) and my time in doing it right.
I'd guess that they agreed to this about 90% of the time and about 85% of the time from that, when they saw the images it was a bit of a revelation followed by something along the lines of " Oh, now I understand what you were talking about".
Even before the shoot you have to think ahead. I usually try and thing backwards.
What is the end goal? Lets say its a shot for an advertising piece.
What iws the ad? Internet, magazine, newspaper, brochure. Say it's a brochure ( because I had this exact thing once) what is the layout? Is it a full page or a skinny DL or something? If it's a DL, you are better off with a tall and long shot ( where possible) than maybe the production department's manager who was left with organising the shoot ideas of a wide panoramic which is going to be tiny in the 2 column layout.
If its newspaper, then no use having a lot of high contrast and colour details in an ad to be printed in low res B/W.
You get the idea.
In saying that, I once got asked to sit in on a production meeting for an ad aimed at tradesmen. I exaggerate not, the " committe" discussed ( argued) for damn near 2 hours just on the make and model phone the guy in the ad for their trade helpline should be holding! They went round the office picking up peoples phones, they were looking on the net and printing out pics, trying to research it as we sat there.... it was mind numbing! I think the thing that really lead them to their decision when they did finally settle on something was me saying " If the viewers of the ad even notice they type of phone the guy is holding, your whole message is lost and the ad is a failure straight off. That seemed to embarras a few of the main procrastinators.
Then another hour went into working out what style of shirt the guy should wear, If chequed was too stereotypical, what colour it should be, what colour overalls, if they should be boilermaker or bib and brace..... 4 hours all up. Thank god I got paid to endure that fiasco.
Took me less that 2 hours to shoot it from arrival to setup to shoot and leaving.
Think ahead to the end goal not just on the shot itself.
The thing is though if you say after the event, "Well I didn't like this location/ setup/ background or whatever and I wouldn't have done it that way" then it IS YOUR fault. Your the shooter, if they knew what they were doing, they wouldn't need to hire you in the first place. If I hired someone to paint my house and afterwards I said that colour is awful and the painter said yeah, I could have told you that, did 2 last week and they looked total crap as well,The guy may be waiting for his money a while for not giving me the benifit of his professional experience and knowledge.
That is what I am paying for after all.
If you forewarn people and it turns to ship as you predicted, that's on them 100% and if they want it done again because they aren't happy, then they are paying full tilt again.
You advised and more importantly covered your arse so if they chose to ignore that advise and end up unhappy, that's on them.
Again though, if you don't prewarn or speak up about your resevations, anything afterwards is and will be seen as a cop out.
It's ridicilous to think every job that comes along is going to be just what you want. Just befcause you don't think it's fantastic and exciting dosen't mean it deserves any less than 100% of your effort. You may be shooting Workboots for a small buisness but the importance of those shots to the business owner who could have the make or break of his business tied up in those boots is far more important than anything else in the world.
Once you have people beating down your door and waving wads of cash at you to shoot for them, sure, only do your dream jobs but till you get to that, you better make the best of the bread and butter job because untill you do them well, The caviar people won't be interested in you.
No matter what you are doing, be the professional and the expert. Look at all the details, the potential pitfalls and let them know. If they go against it, and there may be good reason to for reasons you are not aware of ( and don't underestimate pride) You have covered yourself if they see them and go Yecch.
If you can do it the way you think best after you have done it their way, then you have really covered yourself.
Luckily, profewssional service and covering your butt go hand in hand in most cases.
