24-70 F2.8L Vignette?

I am using a 1DS and the 24-70 F2.8 L V1 and am seeing vignetting at 24mm

Top camera and top lens= Vignetting?

does it still happen if you don't use the hood?

Yes, it is the nature of the lens. You can remove it easily in pp with lens profile
It happens in V2 as well.

Joeseph, no hood needed, it happens bare. Thanks for the info Aliengin.

aliengin wrote in post #16984079
Yes, it is the nature of the lens. You can remove it easily in pp with lens profile
It happens in V2 as well.

I've had the same experience. It vignettes slightly on my 5DIII as well. Easily fixed in PS.

I don't see any info on Canon's sales pitch stating it's vignetting

turbotony wrote in post #16988578
I don't see any info on Canon's sales pitch stating it's vignetting

Would you expect them to state this?

That's what lab reviews are for:

http://www.dpreview.co​m …f-24-70mm-f-2-8l-ii-usm/4

turbotony wrote in post #16988578
I don't see any info on Canon's sales pitch stating it's vignetting

You're seriously complaining about this? Well if it upsets you so much, return it. It's really not that big of a deal.

I am just flat out wondering why they made it.....ok Numen........If you like getting taken for a ride, I will sell you a car with square wheels......no big deal.

Every lens I've owned vignettes when used wide open or close to wide open (particularly at the wide end if a zoom). It's normal and expected.

OP have you EVER looked into vignetting? Do you know what you are talking about?

All lenses have vignetting at their maximum aperture. Check out the $5000 Carl Zeiss Otus (a rather expensive prime, should be noted):

MakisM.5......Yes, I do expect a company to disclose everything about a product, you must work for GM

turbotony wrote in post #16994344
MakisM.5......Yes, I do expect a company to disclose everything about a product, you must work for GM

Did u know your lens also distorts? Requires a camera to be able to capture a picture? Should not be dropped else the glass may break? And your lens also redirects light?

All lenses vignette. Period. It's not something that needs to be stated.

turbotony wrote in post #16994344
MakisM.5......Yes, I do expect a company to disclose everything about a product, you must work for GM

You are wrong!

turbotony wrote in post #16994073
I am just flat out wondering why they made it.....ok Numen........If you like getting taken for a ride, I will sell you a car with square wheels......no big deal.

Not even remotely the same thing. But a car with square wheels would be very obvious. As is vignetting on lenses, so I guess your analogy sorta works.