Brecon Beacons Waterfall

I can't decide whether i prefer the colour, or the black & white, so i thought i'd get your thoughts on it..

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/pAys​Tg

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/pAyt​3p

B&W works better for me on this one. I'd play with adding a bit more contrast to the wall behind the falls as it seems a bit washed out in both versions.

That's all the moisture in the air, it was like a fine mist. I'll have a play with it though... Thanks for the comment

Unfortunate that there were other random people in the shot. I would try to tool around with the content aware tool to remove them from the shot.

JM Photos wrote in post #17243819
Unfortunate that there were other random people in the shot. I would try to tool around with the content aware tool to remove them from the shot.

For me, having someone in the photo gives a useful sense of scale. I like that they are not recognizable; wish their clothing was brighter.

Looks like a very nice waterfall.

[QUOTE=NCSA197;1724606​9]For me, having someone in the photo gives a useful sense of scale. I like that they are not recognizable; wish their clothing was brighter.


IMHO, they are too small and too dark to add more than a distraction to what otherwise is a very nice image. See what the image looks like with them removed.

Thanks guys.. If I get time tomorrow, I'll try removing them. I had the same thoughts about them giving scale to the image, but can see where you're coming from with the distraction comment.

JM Photos wrote in post #17243819
Unfortunate that there were other random people in the shot. I would try to tool around with the content aware tool to remove them from the shot.

Not the question.

beano wrote in post #17243473
I can't decide whether i prefer the colour, or the black & white, so i thought i'd get your thoughts on it..

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/pAys​Tg The Snow Waterfall B&W by stalb, on Flickr

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/pAyt​3p The Snow Waterfall Coulour by stalb, on Flickr

Personally, I prefer the B&W shot.

bw.

Naturalist wrote in post #17246726
Not the question.

Thanks, but I don't have any issue with cc. The more opinions the better, I say.

Naturalist wrote in post #17246728
Personally, I prefer the B&W shot.

tmcman wrote in post #17246998
bw.

Thanks

BW for me.

Naturalist wrote in post #17246726
Not the question.

See if the OP said something like this, I'd respect it. Since you are just a viewer, it makes the comment easy to disregard. If the OP doesn't have an issue with CC then it might be better to just leave your nice comment and move on

beano wrote in post #17247096
Thanks, but I don't have any issue with cc. The more opinions the better, I say.

Thanks beano. I figured it would be better that I told you rather than ignoring what distracted me. What distracted me in the photo will most likely distract many other viewers so I figured you'd rather know.

PS, since the water seems muddy in the colored image, I prefer the BW one.