navydoc wrote in post #17728911
I'm not the expert to answer your questions David but I can relate my personal thoughts. A couple of years ago, I bought a Wacom tablet, the small size. While I loved the idea of it and could see the benefits of using a system that used a pressure sensitive pen, I just couldn't get used to my eyes fixed on my computer monitor while my hand was trying to manipulate the stylus and place it with any precision. Call it poor hand/eye coordination or too many years using a mouse but I gave up in frustration.
The idea of a Wacom tablet that was basically also a monitor that you could 'draw' directly on the screen seems fantastic and would solve my 'patting my stomach/rubbing the top of my head' at the same time delima. Not ever having used one, the only possible negative I can think of is if there is a gap between where the stylus touches the screen and the image below it...kind of like if there is a thick plate of glass between.
If there is no gap and I could afford it, I would buy one in a heartbeat.
There is indeed a gap, but that is yet another thing greatly improved in the 27" - the gap is smaller than ever. I do pretty well with my Intuos Pro tablet, as far as the hand/eye coordination goes, but talk about a gap - that tablet is quite a bit removed from the actual image I am touching. 
vinmunoz wrote in post #17728914
i wish i have cintiq. All i have is a medium size bamboo create. bought the large size first but my hand has to travel farther when retouching and it's not fun for me. more stressful.
Yes, if you are using a tablet (not a Cintiq), then I actually prefer the small wacom. It is indeed cumbersome and wearisome to have to move so far with your arm if your hand/arm movement is disconnected from the image.
Regarding the Cintiq, though, I think the opposite is true. For one thing, if you want to make big moves with the pen with smaller arm movements, then all you need do is zoom out - the image is smaller. And by eliminating that disconnect of where your hand is vs. where the image is, it creates a completely different user experience. So, in my case, my 13" Cintiq companion is acting like a gateway drug - it's small size has left me wanting to go big - as big as possible. 
digital_AM wrote in post #17728945
I also have a medium sized Wacom. Love it. I can't imagine editing without especially for the manual blending I do on my photos.
The Cintiq looks amazing but I cannot justify it nor am I a pure portrait retouched. David, I would say give it a shot!
Thanks Alfredo. I agree. Except for really basic stuff, like global edits etc. I can't stand processing images with a mouse.
Really I am trying to decide between just upgrading my monitor (looking at those cool curved 21:9 monitors
or just going Cintiq. My video gamer self, says get a 21:9, but my serious-about-art self says get the Cintiq.