xpfloyd wrote in post #17832660
Steve Huff - "and tilt shift..no one makes those anymore and while you can get them for Canon and Nikon, they are on the decline
as software does all that a tilt shift lens does these days"
What?!?!? Software can now change the plane of focus in post so that its not square to the sensor?? What software is this - take my money now!
What a moronic statement by Steve. I'm not saying he is a moron, just an architectural photography experience-challenged spook-hunter
saying a stupid thing. If you wish to compose an architectural subject with perspective corrected and you want to maximize your sensor's resolution and sharpness, you can't simply do it in software. You're throwing tons of pixels away and massively re-arranging the rest of them. I do a bunch of perspective correction in software (DXO Viewpoint is excellent), but getting it right in camera is always a better choice if possible. If I were doing arch-photography as a business I wouldn't do it without tilt-shifts.
advaitin wrote in post #17832744
If you can use software to correct perspective, I suppose you could as easily use it to warp perspective.
What Huff fails to understand is that a PC lens will give you a correction that leaves you with a full frame of digital information, rather than a diminished frame of cropped information. Oops, all I did was say what had you already said.
Sorry about that, I was talking half-way to myself as I have been contemplating the idea of selling my 11-24mm and 16-35mm to make a full retreat back to the TS-E 17 and TS-E 24 II combo. Probably won't, but thinking about it. My current project is going through my Lightroom catalog and clearing out all the junk and I'm looking at my old shots with the TS-Es and wishing for them again. If made that retreat, I'd be pining for the good ol' days of having the 11-24mm and 16-35mm. Can't have everything I guess. 