I've had my T3i for about 3 years and maybe 25K clicks. I'm trying to test out a new 80-200 L Drainpipe on it and the focus is all over the place. I'm getting keepers maybe 2 out of 10.
The last telephoto I used before this was a 55-250 about 3 months ago and I'd at least get 8 or 9 out of 10 on the money.
I've been shooting equestrian for several years and never had this issue before using 55-250's, 55-250 STM's and 70-200 f4's ... all at max aperture and usually 1/1250 up to 1/2000.
I'm a little befuddled here. Anyone have any experience with this?? Could it possibly be the Drainpipe??
Focus, when it misses is usually 10 to 20ft behind the subject but often in front as well. I was thinking MFA, which I can't adjust on the Rebel, but that should be consistently one way or another. The camera has always been dead on in the past, and nothing physical (damage wise) has occurred.
Any thoughts would be appreciated!

