I would try single shot center point and focus on the near eye. Try stopping down a small amount for depth of field.
I would try some window light and a higher shutter speed, as was suggested. If you are not getting sharp shots with single point center focus AF and 1/125, then it is time to microadjust the lens. I wouldn't use focus and recompose at close distances and large apertures at first. Depth of field is shallow close up and wide open.


