Phoenixkh wrote in post #17704748
You might already be doing this but just in case.... do your noise reduction before you sharpen. It makes a world of difference.
Completely and utterly not true.
tjs42 wrote in post #17704780
ill try that as i was doing it the other way round
It does not matter in which order you do this. What matters is that you look at the results of one, then go back to the other to refine your results. The effects of LR adjustments are the same no matter which order you do them in, or how many times you go back and forth. The key to noise reduction in LR is to keep both NR and sharpening to a minimum, while applying as much of each as you can get away with.
Noise reduction kills detail. Don't overdo it.
Sharpening enhances noise. Don't overdo it.
My method goes back and forth between sharpening and noise reduction several times looking for that happy medium. If order mattered, my work would be a mess. I do NR, then sharpening, back to NR, then more sharpening, until I get the best results. If you are adjusting one parameter first, then doing the other without looking at the results, you are not getting the best results available. Lightroom is fantastic at noise reduction, if it is used properly.
EDIT:
I can't find them, so I assume I deleted them. But I did some pretty intense noise testing over the summer. Somewhere in POTN, I posted some shots from the 60D at ISO 12,800 (EDIT: 6400, sorry) and from the 6D at ISO 102,400. Both had extremes of highlights and shadow. Neither displayed any visible noise, even in the shadows. Admittedly, those shots were staged, on a tripod, and processed heavily. The processing was a bit time-consuming, but I proved to myself that ISO settings are mostly irrelevant to your results. Shoot the ISO that gets the job done.
EDIT w/correction. The 60D shots are at ISO 6400, not 12,800. My point stands. Here is the link:
https://photography-on-the.net …showthread.php?p=17566142