Eastport wrote in post #17891839
Alan:
Maybe you are right, but there's a bunch of sites out there stressing over the lack of an anti-moire filter on the 6D - thus making the video files not as clean as the 5D3.
If it has one, why are people make a big deal about Mosaic Engineering (in addition to, of course, Mosaic itself) making such a filter (for about $365) for the 6D? Is it because the filter is there on the 6D but just not as effective as it is on the 5D3?
For example,
http://www.canonwatch.com …ing-anti-aliasing-filter/
I read it on the internet. It has to be true...
Moire (which may or may not be wholly down to aliasing effects at the sensor) in video is a very different matter to shooting stills. it really depends on how they are taking data from the sensor to convert to 1920 pixel wide video. The 6D, and all of the 20-22 MPix 35mm sensors are pretty low resolution, with a similar linear resolution to a 20D, of about 8 MPix from the 22.5×15mm APS-C area. Because the 6D sensor is so large, 36mm wide, it means that you are taking the approx 5600 pixels from the sensor, and having to output that at only 1920 pixels wide. That is only 53 Pixels/mm, and that equates to a resolution of only 27 LP/mm. If you are not very careful in down converting the output from the sensor you will induce aliasing artifacts during the process. The latest MK II lenses from Canon are starting to deliver detail to the sensor at approaching 120 LP/mm, or 4.4× the Nyquist limit of the video output.
Lets face it even cinema 4K at 4096 pixels wide only offers a resolution 57 LP/mm and you would need to double it again to 8K to match the linear resolution of a 19 MPix APS-C sensor, which on a 36mm wide sensor will deliver 114 LP/mm, or about the limit of the best lenses. A 3:2 ratio 36×24mm sensor of this resolution will have approx 50 MPix i.e. the same as the 5DS.
Unless you are able to do 8K from a 36×24mm sensor you will always have to be very careful how you downsample the video stream. Actually the 22.5×15mm APS-C frame is much closer to the traditional 35mm cine format, which is a frame across the width of the film stock. I have seen suggestions that converting traditional 35m film prints to a 4K video format would be an ideal option for producing 4K video is sensible, 3:2 ratio 4K video is about 11 Mpix, a good choice for an APS-C sized sensor too, matching the old film stock.
Alan