I feel like the online depth of field calculators and cheat sheets do more harm than good for most new photographers, because the majority of them don't consider reproduction size or viewing distance of the final image, nor take into account post-production cropping. There are assumptions made by these calculators that are either buried in fine print that people don't read, or not stated at all, but are critical to interpretation of the numbers. Most of these calculators are giving you numbers for an 8" x 10" print held at a viewing distance of 12", which is similar in view angle to a 27" monitor at 2 feet.
Where people get confused most often in the digital age, is when they pixel peep. If you zoom into 1:1 to check focus, things that the DoF calculator told you would be in sharp focus will very likely not be.
My advice for the real-world scenario (group photo) here is figure out proper exposure, and then take the shot at a few different apertures, adjusting the shutter speed or ISO as needed to keep the exposure the correct. Then, get a feel for what works for your camera and viewing size and don't worry so much about the math. With landscape work and product photography, this empirical process is even easier, since you can take as many shots as you want. Eventually, you'll just know from experience what is going to work best in typical situations.
bumpintheroad wrote in post #17915806
The actual DOF is going to vary according to (A) your sensor size (full frame vs crop), (B) your focal length, (C) your aperture, and (D) distance to your focus point.
Only C and D are directly relevant. A and B are indirectly relevant in that they influence your choice of subject distance (D). Viewing size/resolution should be on this list instead of A and B, in my opinion.