Vintage dining

Which shot do you like better? CC welcome

If simply done for memories then I would prefer the color so I remembered the true nature of everything.

Ok I'll bite. What's the story that goes with this scene?

It's just an outdoor meeting/eating spot at Eldorado Canyon in Nv. I just thought it would be a neat place for a gathering.

Color or b/w, perhaps more contrast? Or crop in closer to the fireplace.

Have you considered the roadside picture?

The original picture, and it's b/w conversion both appear to be "too cleaned up" for me. But I don't know exactly what you were aiming for.

The roadside picture has more character too me with the old Coca Cola sign, old truck (Jeep?) and stumps.

atexasphotog wrote in post #17964747
I just thought it would be a neat place for a gathering.

If you're using the photo to show a group this place where you're suggesting they meet, I think the color version would go further toward persuading them.

You have found a neat location...work the site to find the bestest viewpoint...nice shot though.

atexasphotog wrote in post #17964747
It's just an outdoor meeting/eating spot at Eldorado Canyon in Nv. I just thought it would be a neat place for a gathering.

Hosted photo: posted by atexasphotog in
./showthread.php?p=179​64747&i=i24617216
forum: Critique Corner

Thanks for the info.