Whats Wrong with this Shot

Thanks

Isnt it weird that adding a fancy extra light made it more ordinary looking

Well, here goes my opinion, I like them both.. and instead of trying to match the other lights, I would have opted for something radically different, a blue, red or green gel on her.. because we are often awash in lights of different colors, particularly on the street. Why not mix it up more? JMHO YMMV.