What the heck should I focus on in Photoshop

BokehBender wrote in post #18668867
I should probably just keep going through other peoples photos and find effects and designs I admire and then learn the tools to match those goals.

That's a good way to expand your horizons and learn to see images with fresh eyes. Check the photo I posted here. Looking only at the 'before' version, it might not occur to you to change the light as selectively (and drastically) as I did. But once you see it and learn how to do it, you'll find that the same technique can be applied in a variety of ways to a many photos.

You can browse more before-and-after images on my website, here.

Thanks everyone! You have given me several hours of great resources to dive into and a new perspective Love the ideas.

And sorry digital paradise. For some reason when I was shooting in the park that day I only shot JPEG (I know, Im just as ashamed as you are of me haha)

I think the lesson is that everyone has their own preference for
1) how much they want to manipulate their images vs SOOC
2) what tools they prefer for a workflow that suits their own needs.

For my style of photography, I tend towards the side of SOOC with simple croppping, tone correction and highlight/shadow adjustments
DPP suits me for 80% of my needs.

I use PS with a couple of plugins for easily seeing some adjustments on certain images (Topaz Clarity) and sometimes for noise reduction.

I tried hard to like LR but in the end it was just too much overhead for my needs.

BokehBender wrote in post #18670705
Thanks everyone! You have given me several hours of great resources to dive into and a new perspective Love the ideas.

And sorry digital paradise. For some reason when I was shooting in the park that day I only shot JPEG (I know, Im just as ashamed as you are of me haha)

NP. Nothing wrong with Jpeg.

Gregsiem wrote in post #18670739
I think the lesson is that everyone has their own preference for
1) how much they want to manipulate their images vs SOOC
2) what tools they prefer for a workflow that suits their own needs.

For my style of photography, I tend towards the side of SOOC with simple croppping, tone correction and highlight/shadow adjustments
DPP suits me for 80% of my needs.

I use PS with a couple of plugins for easily seeing some adjustments on certain images (Topaz Clarity) and sometimes for noise reduction.

I tried hard to like LR but in the end it was just too much overhead for my needs.

If I had no other choice I would have not issues just using DPP. I always cull images using DPP before I import into LR.

Tom Reichner wrote in post #18668795
A more effective way to approach this would be to have a photo that you really wish was different - you know, where you have this clear idea of exactly what you want the photo to look like, and then you should ask, "How can I use Photoshop to make this photo look like the image in my mind's eye."

This is primarily a post for appreciation and emphasis.

Many moons ago when first encountered the then relatively primitive PS that was exactly what I ended up doing.

Today I am a full-blown PS expert and still follow Tom's advice with a liberal application of Google. The universe of PS users is large and prolific enough to make continuous learning not only possible but great fun.

The essential attribute is every in always, as Tom says, that "image in the mind's eye." With that accomplished it's just time and work.

The answer is quite simple Focus on what you want to do with your photographs. Do you want to change contrast? Learn the many ways you can do that? Do I want to remove foreign objects cluttering your image? Learn how to remove objects. Do you want to fix light flare? Learn that. There are tons of free videos. Your learning in Photoshop is for the long haul. You won't and don't need to learn everything, especially everything all at once. Think of this analogy. If you bought car, you don't sit and think of the possibility of what the car can do, but instead where you want the car to take you.

kjonnnn wrote in post #18674635
The answer is quite simple Focus on what you want to do with your photographs. Do you want to change contrast? Learn the many ways you can do that? Do I want to remove foreign objects cluttering your image? Learn how to remove objects. Do you want to fix light flare? Learn that. There are tons of free videos. Your learning in Photoshop is for the long haul. You won't and don't need to learn everything, especially everything all at once. Think of this analogy. If you bought car, you don't sit and think of the possibility of what the car can do, but instead where you want the car to take you.

Helloooo?
https://photography-on-the.net …showthread.php?​p=18668795

Hello what?

I think in principle the "decide where you want to go with the image" advice is sound.

But that is not how I learned to work in a darkroom and that is not how I learned to use Photoshop. I learned the various processes which would be useful. This is how you develop film. This is how you load it in the enlarger. This is how you decide what crop you want. This is how you make sure it is sharp. This is how you make sure to find the right Exposure. This is how you can adjust the contrast. This is how you dodge and burn. Etc.

Once I had the basic tools, I would look at my images and make decisions about what would benefit that image.

So I will offer a different perspective and suggest that there are a set of tools and processes within Photoshop which are generally worth knowing if you want to do basic adjustments in Photoshop and there are a larger set of tools which are worthwhile if you want to do sophisticated things in Photoshop. And then there are another set of tools which you might want to know if you want to do artistic things.

As a photographer, there are a limited set of tools and procedures which will be generally useful. As mentioned in a joke above about PS being for designers, I will agree this much: a large portion of the tools and procedures in PS are for graphic artists and designers. But there are still some number (300?) which are useful to the serious photographer-craftsman.

How to learn this set of skills? The best is to take a class from a competent teacher. There are many good videos on YouTube. And many bad ones. Sifting through is the challenge.

The Martin Evening book mentioned above is a good reference. Eismann finally updated PS Restoration and Retouching (with others, who probably did the heavy lifting). The 4th edition just came out on Kindle and will be in print any day now. She also has another book which is old but still useful on compositing.

Julianne Kost works for Adobe and has put out much useful material over the years in video and articles, most of which are free.

Lacking a good teacher, I recommend looking at places you pay for video lessons because the material tends to be much better organized to you can learn skills which build on each other and get some comprehension of a sensible workflow. You will ultimately develop your own workflow. Having someone show you a sensible one will get you started.

Lynda.com was a good starting point for me for a general understanding of the overall tools. You pay monthly and there are several instructors who have overview classes to understand tools relevant to a photographer. This is not a bad place to get a foundation.

There are also some good options on CreativeLive.com. You can see free classes when they are "broadcast" and if you use the app, you can watch any single segment for free once a day. And they have plenty of sales where you can get a good deal. If you PM me, I can send you a code for $15 off a first class (full disclosure: my only relationship is as a customer, but I also get $15 off if you use the coupon).

I have my own preferences for instructors on Lynda and CL. There are some other good sources, but these are the two best aimed at a beginner. There are many good free videos on YouTube for learning specific things, but nothing I have found is both good and systematic for developing skills.

To be clear, I am not disagreeing with the advice above. When you first start with an important image, you don't want to just "fool around in PS" till it looks good. You want to decide what you want to do with the image and then begin.

But...when you are still learning the tools, you DO want to fool around with images, experiment and figure out what is possible. So that, when you are ready to work on a "serious" image, you will have the skills.

F2Bthere wrote in post #18684125
I think in principle the "decide where you want to go with the image" advice is sound.

But that is not how I learned to work in a darkroom and that is not how I learned to use Photoshop. I learned the various processes which would be useful. This is how you develop film. This is how you load it in the enlarger. This is how you decide what crop you want. This is how you make sure it is sharp. This is how you make sure to find the right Exposure. This is how you can adjust the contrast. This is how you dodge and burn. Etc.

Once I had the basic tools, I would look at my images and make decisions about what would benefit that image.

\

Same here...an excellent perspective