AlanU wrote in post #18719212
Some non Fuji user will read this thread maybe looking for some visual comparison regarding high iso images.
https://www.youtube.com …ontinue=980&v=iBAMOvlZ8qg
If you start looking at 13:00 into this older video regarding Fuji X-t1 this is just a visual difference from consumer grade Nikon aps-c body and Fuji X-t1. It still appears Fuji is still using the SOS (ISO) standard. Since Nikon/Canon/Sony uses REI this is never a real good indication of apples to apples comparison. ...
Because there is really no magical adjustment factor to use that would make the Fujifilm and Canon ISOs comparable in any meaningful way, the simplest comparison would be to set up each camera so that they are shooting JPEG, with a neutral picture style or film sim, custom white balanced in the scene and setting the aperture and shutter to identical settings. Then the ISO of each camera would be adjusted to get a similar JPEG rendering in terms of overall image brightness. For example, set up the first camera with fixed aperture and custom WB. Set the camera on ISO 200 and adjust shutter speed until you get a gray target exposed "properly." Then set up the second camera with the same aperture, custom WB and the same shutter speed as the "properly" exposed image from the first camera and then adjust ISO on the second camera to get a JPEG image that is as close as possible to the "properly" exposed image from the first camera. Now you have a direct comparison between ISOs.
You could do this across the range of ISO and you could do it in both directions - that is, use the Fujifilm camera as the "first" camera and sweep through its ISO range, replicating each Fujifilm ISO with the corresponding Canon ISO; then switch and use the Canon as the reference camera and replicate each ISO image form the Canon with the corresponding FUjifilm ISO setting that gives identical results to the Canon.
Although this would be a more empirical approach to comparing ISO, it would be a direct comparison and you could plot the relationship between Fujifilm ISO and Canon ISO directly instead of assuming some scale factor that, even if it is meaningful, may not be constant across the ISO range.
I no longer have my Canon equipment, otherwise I would do the comparison and publish it here. I can try it with my Ricoh GRII and my X-H1 for a proof of concept though.
kirk