I have been scanning old family photos, slides, and negatives for several years. Recently I picked up a Plustek negative scanner and it does a fantastic job, so good that the film grain is very visible. I have been looking at picking up the Topaz Photo AI suite but before dishing out $200, I was wondering if anyone has used this on scanned photos, slides, or negatives. What I'm wondering is:
1. Does Topaz handle film grain like noise? I've tried using Adobe's noise processing but it does not do much even when I put the slider at 100
2. Does Topaz work with .tif and .dng files? All my scans are either tif or dng. Unfortunately, Adobe's Denoise doesn't seem to work with these files.
3. Any real life experience would be appreciated especially with scanned photos/negatives/ and slides..
I posted two samples below that show the problem well. The fils is Kodacolor CII from the early 80's. The main image was under exposed so it shows grain clearly. Also, they are %200 screen shots so the grain is clearly visable.
The first image - Left side was scanned with an Epson V600 and VueScan and the right side scanned with PlusTek and also VueScan with the same parameters.
The second image is scanned with the PlusTec with the left image with no noise reduction and the right image with Luminance turned up to 100, Detail up to 50 and color up to 50. It's a bit better but still real grainy.
THIS IS A LOW QUALITY PREVIEW. Please log in to see the good quality stuff.
THIS IS A LOW QUALITY PREVIEW. Please log in to see the good quality stuff.




