Something wierd is going on with her arm in #3, Looks like the contrast or saturation was cranked if thats the way they came out of the camera, or maybe too much USM? I just donno! The pose in #2 is very nice, #1 I have to agree with everyone about the tree and I might add you could have lowered your perspective to get more eye level, #3 is a nice pose but could use a little tweaking, have her turn her body just a little more towards the rail and then rotate her upper body and head to be looking at you. One more thing, you might leave a little more room above the heads, as I have found parents like to order large prints or just 8x10s and you are gonna want room to get a good crop expecially with out chopping off tops of heads. (makes you look really unprofessional!) Other than those few things I think you did a super job for your 2nd try at Srs. and 1st time w/ a female!

I was looking at her right arm. I see the shadow you're talking about. and I think I agree with your flash theory.
