liza wrote in post #2019954
It's okay if you stop it down to f/8. And he can always use foot zoom with the 50mm until he can afford a good midrange. That's what I did for about 18 years. Never did own a short zoom lens when I shot film.

I notice, from your signature, your shortest focal length lens is 28mm. That would put it in the 'normal' focal length range for an APS size sensor. I find it interesting that 5 of the 8 lenses (all primes) you list cover 85mm -200mm exclusively. And, that the range is repeated with a 6th lens (a zoom). Especially having the experence with photography that you do; I would not even consider challenging your selections, for you that is. However, I would venture a guess that the vast majority of shutterbugs would want something wider than a short telephoto in their stable either from the start or near start of their collection. I think it would be interesting, entertaining and informative to have a poll that adresses the question. I'm going to start one when I finish this posting and hope it will be fun. I'm also prepared to be surprised and enlightened.