canon 28-105 vs canon 28-200

I have been doing alot of reading on these two lenses. From what i have read the 28-105 is a great lens. My question is does anyone have both lenses or have experieces with both lenses. Is the 28-200 as good as the 28-105. Am I losing anything by the longer focal length, and if so what am I losing. Is it worth the longer lenght or should i stick with the 105. Thanks for all your help.

ben4633 wrote in post #2019139
I have been doing alot of reading on these two lenses. From what i have read the 28-105 is a great lens. My question is does anyone have both lenses or have experieces with both lenses. Is the 28-200 as good as the 28-105. Am I losing anything by the longer focal length, and if so what am I losing. Is it worth the longer lenght or should i stick with the 105. Thanks for all your help.

Here is the 28-200

Here is the 28-105 f3.5-4.5 (the good one)

If you are talking about this 28-105 f4-5.6 STAY AWAY!!

The good one 28-105 f3.5-4.5 seems like the best bet.