i like nr2 and nr3
you could have avoided the shade on the right side of the nose though (pic3). loving the skin tones.I agree, your lighting has the shadow falling into the eye at an upward angle. Not very flattering. If you are trying to light fromt he side then have the shadow fall into the labial fold between the cheek and nose. This techique works very well with those clients that have a deep or multiple layer fold.
Keep trying,
Les Baldwin




