Cokin P wide angle holder

I recently bought a Tokina 12-24 lens when using the standard Cokin P holder I have a small amount of vignetting when using filters if I changed to the wide angle holder would this solve the problem? I use Adobe elements 4 which I understand does not have the same features as CS2 to correct vignetting.

I do not want to move up to Cokin Z as its more cost better spent on a new Lens!! your comments please

You could try dumping the holder and holding the filter in place with BluTack. Sounds madness but I did see it in a camera magazine. After my initial disbelief I concluded it might work.

Didnt think of that John Blu tak added to both of my camera bags!!!

John Sims wrote in post #2135670
You could try dumping the holder and holding the filter in place with BluTack. Sounds madness but I did see it in a camera magazine. After my initial disbelief I concluded it might work.

Of course it would work, but it wouldn't be as easy or as reliable as a wide angle holder. I don't see why not just go with one of the wide holders, they're quite cheap.

The Cokin P wide angle holder will work fine but only allows use one filter at a time. Works like a charm on my EF-S 10-22mm lens.