Hi folks. Thanks for your critiques. The first ring was my own "director's cut", not to be used by the client. Other people I have shown the image too commented on any distracting reflection and most people seem to say they don't want anything to distract from the beautiful ring. The client wanted velvet, which wasn't my first choice to do, but I decided to give it a go.
I have a couple more ring views to post if you have time to check out, and yes it is certainly ok to try out your edits and such. That's why we come here, to get other ideas, advice and examples of other interpretations.
From Athena's comment about blacks, I can't tell you how many tweaks I tried with levels and curves to decide what would remain black and contrast with highlights. Shooting the ring on black, clear acrylic and white present each set of challenges.
Another issue is whether or not to keep the band in sharp focus or blur it because the band has these very prominent impressions. There are so many possibilities in shooting jewelry and it is a tough, patient process to pull off successfully.
Thanks katt
Canon 10D and 30D. Tokina 80-200mm Pro 2.8 zoom, Sigma 50mm 2.8 macro, Sigma 10-20mm f4-5.6, Canon 28-135mm f3.5-5.6 IS, 2 AB 800