135L + 1.4xII vs 200L on 5D

I received a email requesting a comparison. Shot with 5D - iso200 - f2.8 - 1/4000 sec - tripod & release. The (( 3 )) was my focus point.
Shot 1 - 135L + 1.4XII

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

Shot 2 - 200L

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

Shot 1 - cropped

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

Shot 2 - cropped

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

Focus speed seemed the same.

1DsIII - 1D IV - 5DS R - IR Rebel -TS-E17L - 14L II - 35L - 135L - 400L 5.6 - 50 Compact Macro - Sigma 60 - 600 - 2 x 580EX II & CP-E3 - 270EX II - 1.4xII - 25mm Ext. - Angle Finder C - Induro/Induro - SkimmerPod II - Toshiba I7 - NEC Spectraview - Pro 9000 II

gear | flickr

Jaetie wrote in post #2591393
IQ seems about there on both lenses. the quality of the 135L is just amazing.

The 5D does L lenses justice, I never achieved these results with the 1D or 10D.

There was no post-processing at all, factor setting on the 5D.

The 5D was money well spent.

1DsIII - 1D IV - 5DS R - IR Rebel -TS-E17L - 14L II - 35L - 135L - 400L 5.6 - 50 Compact Macro - Sigma 60 - 600 - 2 x 580EX II & CP-E3 - 270EX II - 1.4xII - 25mm Ext. - Angle Finder C - Induro/Induro - SkimmerPod II - Toshiba I7 - NEC Spectraview - Pro 9000 II

David
my stuff - [URL="http://www.pbase​.com/davideb"]my gallery - [URL="http://photograp​hy-on-the.net/forum/showpost​.php?p=3928125&postcou​nt=1"]go Rats!

DavidEB wrote in post #2594481
useful comparison, thanks.

so would you buy the 200 again, knowing these results?

For football and soccer the 200L + 1.4xII is very good, and with 3 bodies and a wife and a 19 year old son, we use all the gear.

I'm the gearhead of the family

1DsIII - 1D IV - 5DS R - IR Rebel -TS-E17L - 14L II - 35L - 135L - 400L 5.6 - 50 Compact Macro - Sigma 60 - 600 - 2 x 580EX II & CP-E3 - 270EX II - 1.4xII - 25mm Ext. - Angle Finder C - Induro/Induro - SkimmerPod II - Toshiba I7 - NEC Spectraview - Pro 9000 II

Psychic1 wrote in post #2594547
For football and soccer the 200L + 1.4xII is very good, and with 3 bodies and a wife and a 19 year old son, we use all the gear.

I'm the gearhead of the family

wow, that's must be tons of photos from a game. 3 cameras w/ a total of like 16 fps?

you're making me want a 5D all the more over the 30D replacement.

gear | flickr

Tom
5D IV, M5, RP, & various lenses