1Ds MARKII vs. 5D (tests)

coreypolis wrote in post #2599371
exif tells us the camera

Yeah, you're right. I was way off!

Oooh...I like #2. I like #2...#2!!!
Too late to change my mind?

Tareq wrote in post #2599530
No, #1 is 1Ds2 and #2 is 5D

Second shot looks just a LITTLE cleaner?
At least it does to my eyes.

What do you think Tareq?

Tareq wrote in post #2599527
Test Result 1:
All what i want to say is that both shots are 100% crop, both at same settings with same lens, all @ ISO 3200.

Hey, Tareq. Go do a side by side test this weekend with both cameras. Use the same settings, shoot the same scene and use the same lens. Then post this comparo guessing game again next week. I'm anxious to see the results of that one.

Tareq wrote in post #2599547
Test Result 2:

1- 1Ds MARK2

2- 5D


again, both taken with same lens (50 1.4) at ISO 3200, both 100% crop.

The 5D does look better. Guess I don't need to set my sights on that 1Ds now.

Looks like the focus was off in the first. Compare the background text and you see that the focal point was behind the jar label somewhere.

Lord_Malone wrote in post #2599541
Hey, Tareq. Go do a side by side test this weekend with both cameras. Use the same settings, shoot the same scene and use the same lens. Then post this comparo guessing game again next week. I'm anxious to see the results of that one.

My friends told me that tomorrow they will go to a nature place which have landscapes and so, i feel tired but i think i will try to go then i will take both cameras and i will try to have both scenes from both camera with same settings and lens and will see how it will be different in IQ or Noise if i will use high ISO, not sure if i will go, i am tired (sick with flu).

Tareq wrote in post #2599557
My friends told me that tomorrow they will go to a nature place which have landscapes and so, i feel tired but i think i will try to go then i will take both cameras and i will try to have both scenes from both camera with same settings and lens and will see how it will be different in IQ or Noise if i will use high ISO, not sure if i will go, i am tired (sick with flu).

Tareq, we really don't give a damn if you're sick. You owe this to the POTN community! Now be a man, suck it up, and get your ass out there tomorrow and bring us some test shots!!

I noticed that as well. Seems like it's on text on the box behind the lens...

But it seems like the 5D image is cleaner.

rowdyred94 wrote in post #2599555
Looks like the focus was off in the first. Compare the background text and you see that the focal point was behind the jar label somewhere.

If your tripod is giving you problems with getting things level, there are a few 'quick' things you can do to help...

1. Use the focus points in the viewfinder to line the horizon up
2. on the 5D buy the Ee-D focusing screen - it has grid lines marked on it.
3. you can get a bubble level that clips onto the flash hotshoe and you can use that to make sure your camera is level.



Hope that helps.

Tareq, you better listen to the Lord!!!

Lord_Malone wrote in post #2599569
Tareq, we really don't give a damn if you're sick. You owe this to the POTN community! Now be a man, suck it up, and get your ass out there tomorrow and bring us some test shots!!

Lord_Malone wrote in post #2599569
Tareq, we really don't give a damn if you're sick. You owe this to the POTN community! Now be a man, suck it up, and get your ass out there tomorrow and bring us some test shots!!

hehe, you are tempting me.
I am sure you will do the same if you sick, but you will never tell.

anyway, i have to sleep then as it is only 4 hours for now before we go there very early in the morning.

I will complete the test first.

Tareq wrote in post #2599592
hehe, you are tempting me.
I am sure you will do the same if you sick, but you will never tell.

anyway, i have to sleep then as it is only 4 hours for now before we go there very early in the morning.

I will complete the test first.

That's the spirit! Look forward to seeing the results.

Test Result 3:


1- 1Ds MARKII

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/png'

2- 5D

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/png'

Sure 5D owners are happy now, hehe