It’s pretty much been said but I do want to add just a bit in response to some of Lotto’s comments.
You said that you couldn’t put a diffusion panel over the subject for a product shot. I respectfully have to say that is simply not correct.
I have been using panels suspended over products and customers for decades and it’s far easier and faster than trying to position a huge soft box hanging from a heavy boom that takes up a lot of floor space. With two small light stands and Photoflex T clamps, it’s a simple task to place a large panel over any subject you desire. I have even done this for a couple who wanted a romantic portrait of themselves together.
The panel can easily be raised up or down, positioned at any angle and tilted all in only seconds without any hassles' at all. In a working studio one has to be able to create whatever lighting is needed and do it fast and efficiently. The panel excels at this. There are two examples of commercial product images below that show a large panel suspended over the work table with other lighting devices being used at the same time. You can also see what a T clamp looks like. Once attached to a light stand, you just snap your panel right into it and you are done. Easy.
With regard to the comment “...moving the diffusion panel then readjust the light is just too slow for me...”
I can’t figure that one out because that it the number one advantage of working with panels. Speed. It’s no more difficult than just grabbing the light and moving it. Speed is a big advantage with panels and as has been discussed many times in these forums, with a soft box you are stuck with only one size light whereas with a panel, you have an unlimited number of different sizes all instantly available.
With regard to the other comment about butterfly lighting, you said that it can’t be done with a panel. Again, that is simply not true. I do it all the time. I demonstrate it at all of my seminars. If one wishes to do straight on butterfly lighting, a panel can be set up just like with the commercial product. For portrait work however, butterfly lighting is not usually the best choice because, you are lighting the subject ear to ear which adds weight to the subject. It’s fine for slender face models who have small ears but for the average person it’s not always a flattering lighting pattern.
Creating butterfly lighting with a floor standing panel is also extremely easy when we have the subject turned in the typical 2/3 portrait view showing only one ear. The panel lights the face precisely perpendicular as is required with fast adjustment done easily.
Lastly, you said that you can’t do under lighting with a panel. Why? I do. A panel is quickly and easily position below and in front of a subject at whatever angle and position is needed. Once again I do this all the time and it’s easy. A lot of people don’t yet understand all the advantages of diffusion panels but little by little they are learning and enjoying the extra control they have.
You are right about one thing, however. I won’t be taking my 7 foot panel into the bathroom to do photography. I will be taking my 3 foot panel.
Best wishes,
HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.
HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.