Phil V wrote in post #2668461
Never found a need for using backgrounds for anything other than straight 'record shots'.
My personal style is to capture the events of the day. If all I can come up with is using a background, I may as well save everyone the bother of having me there on the day. I can just invite them round here at my convenience and shoot them in front of the background (might as well do it after the honeymoon, when they're nice and tanned).
If the church interior isn't suitable for formals, shoot them somewhere that is, If the backgrounds are distracting for head and shoulders shots, that's why I have fast lenses.
It's my job to find the images that tell the story, of course some photographers consider it their job to 'create' the images of the day. It's a different outlook I suppose.
To the OP I suggest you look at the thread
here to see how many great WPs actually resort to just unfurling a background.
The person that started this post was a 'Studio Portrait Photographer' and wanted information about background colors to use for an upcoming wedding. I suggested grey and then provided some other possible backgrounds, and even background projection systems.
Frankly, I don't lug a background myself, to most weddings, unless they specifically ask me to, and I try to make the most of the settings and locations. But on the other hand some times the only place (you have the room to shoot formals) is 'not good', so a background system with studio lighting, and that can affect the number of prints sold.
As far as people that have done portraits using backgrounds, I would like to provide my own list of photographers. Richard Avedon, Irving Penn, Joseph Karsh, maybe that is enough to make my point. A photograph is judged on it's aesthetic value, for what it conveys to the viewer. Whether the photograph was set up, and the subjects directed into giving a personal glimpse into their feelings, or if it came naturally from a photojournalistic candid, they both serve the same need.
In Susan Sontag's book "On Photography" she discusses Wedding Photography in particular, and I would suggest you take the time to read it. She was Anne Liebovitz's long time companion and friend. And coincidentally when Anne's sister was married Joe Bussnick was thrilled to be asked to shoot the wedding. One of the Worlds Greatest Portrait Photographers hired a wedding photojournalist to shoot the wedding! Go figure!!
Joe