which pic looks better?

I took this pic along with several others in a series at around 715pm. Sun was just barely up above the ramapo mountains. I used new adjustment layes for layers/curves/contrast​/saturation/selective color on both images along with USM.

Both pics are the same shot just different adjustments.

This first one I didn't use any noise removal at all. Was shot at ISO400.

You are right, the first looks better, but they both seem to have kind of a yellow cast to them. I also would have put the train further into the picture.

i did, but stupid me when i had made corrections i saved it, but not to a new file but right back to the memory card. So i wiped out the original file that i could'vd worked on again tonight.

I think #1 looks better...EricL

What do you think of this? curves adjustment to add shadows and decrease brightness.... USM for contrast, and a little color correction...

oops.. the attachment would be nice, wouldn't it... here you go....

HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.

Colors are better now

The colour balance in the edit Kristy made is allot better. Although it seems darker now and some detail has been lost to shadow. Maybe a little shadow/highlight to round it out?