I am not familiar with the S 2IS. However, I think you are referring to exposure compensation. I have found that +1 with a clear sky is helpful with my camera (a 30D). I have had to use as much as +2 on a bright overcast day. Exposure compensation is wonderful for bringing out detail in your subject against a bright background. This is helpful in a lot of other situations too. If your camera is set to aperture priority, compensating + will decrease your speed. Could be a disaster if you are shooting moving subjects. If you underexpose your subject and try to brighten it up in post processing you will end up with a noisy image. If you are going to miss the exposure, it is best to miss a little on the hot or + side so you will be darkening it a little in post processing.
All this said, nothing beats an incident meter.