The new Canons and Nikon released this fall are based on 14-bit A/D converters, meaning they now are capable of producing ≈16,000 discrete tonal values. Can someone who understands more about this technology fill us in on how this affects past discussions on this forum and Luminous Landscape about the strategy of "Exposing to the Right" (here
, here, and here
).
Tell me if I am wrong, but in a normal 5-stop Dynamic Range a 14-bit chip would produce 512 tonal values in the darkest F-stop and 256 levels in the stop below that. This is (literally) exponentially more information than was available with a 12-bit chip (128 and 64 values respectively). And blows away the paltry 8-bit chip in the shadow areas.
I assume this 14-bit chip is the reason Canon decided to include the "Highlight Tone Priority" function. This function (as revealed by others
) simply under exposes the scene one stop by increasing the ISO, then bumps back up in post (In the RAW converter for RAW or in camera for JPGs). Isn't this effectively "Shooting to the Left"?
With a 14-bit A/D the camera can shoot a stop darker but still have twice the tonal range of a 12-bit chip, right?
Does all this mean that "Shooting to the Right" is now overkill? It would still give a broader range of tonal values to work with but is there a perceptible advantage to use the 8k stop when the next stop down still has 4k?
An ancillary question is what happens to the tonal ranges below 6 stops? are there still 64 tonal values 8 stops darker than "paper white"? Are those values salvageable?
Can a 14-bit chip get close to the High Dynamic Range images created by bracketing?
If someone understands this stuff please enlighten us!

