Strange then how with this shot it seems he has something wrong? imagine new members see this shot then they will think it is not done properly, and to be honest i didn't look at his others posts to judge his skill.
I explained why something is wrong. At times we all lose objectivity and take a technique or use of a plug-in too far.
I can't even begin to count the number or times I worked on an image for a while, stepped away from the computer and then came back to it and had one of those "what was I thinking"? moments.
The shot is executed well. The OP knows how to use Photoshop, layers, masks, etc. I believe he just lacked the objectivity to see the unnatural looking skin of over-softening in some areas.
I don't think it matters what new members think. This is not a tutorial and no one is saying "hey, do what this guy does, he's an expert". Suppose the effect was intended. No matter how much you or I don't like it, if it is what the artist intends then no one has to like it, or understand it or copy the technique.
That's the beauty of art. There are no rules.
