Samanax wrote in post #5085442
Many people who this book is recommended to
are beginners or new to DSLR photography and I'm sure it's of great help to them (I know it is to me).
Yes, they are. I agree. But I've seen it recommended almost as a sort of panacea or something, to people who should know better (i.e. not beginners).
Samanax wrote in post #5085442
Over-rated? Possibly...but as you say, that's your humble opinion. If others feel this is a great book, that's
their opinion. We're allowed to express our opinions here, aren't we?
I've never said or implied otherwise, have I?
I like books, and I encourage people to buy them. At $17, it's tough not to recommend the book. But it just seems to me that, at times, some people treat it as a sort of holy grail or something. It won't help your composition, your hand-holding technique, it won't give you extra reach, etc. It's a book about exposure.
I place a high value on tips, so for $17 or whatever you don't need to get much out of the book. However, I also feel it's somewhat fair to say that the information contained in the book could probably be summed up in a pamphlet. 
I see your point, and "over-recommended" sounds good too, but I'm not giving up on "over-rated" just yet. I think it's repetitive. I think he could have abstracted the "brother" stuff (Brother Dense Forest Foliage?
) into a separate chapter rather than scatter them throughout, etc. Photoguy comments on the "cheesiness" too, for example.
I didn't say how MUCH I thought it was over-rated. Again, for only $17, it can't be much at all. And if you can sell it to someone else on the forum for $10 after you're done, that's only $7. 