Logo Critique

Here are 3 logos I designed for a local business owner. Her basic requirements were the blue/gold color and being associated with Peachtree City, GA.
Sorry for the image size, photobucket seems to want to mess up when I try to resize.

HTTP response: 404 | Byte size: ZERO | PHOTOBUCKET ERROR IMAGE

HTTP response: 404 | Byte size: ZERO | PHOTOBUCKET ERROR IMAGE

HTTP response: 404 | Byte size: ZERO | PHOTOBUCKET ERROR IMAGE

The fonts used in them don't do anything for me. Too fancy, too much going on. The third is the simplest but the tree is too busy. I'd try to simplify it because really with so much going on in all these and the bad color combinations its not easy to look at or read.

oh yeah forgot, She picked the font too. She wanted some kind of script form.

I think the second one is the best of the three. I don't have any problem with the font at all or with them being too busy but to me the first and third shots look unfinished.

Just my $.02 worth,
Jim

The fancy script is not attracting my attention...maybe keep it simpler?

I like the second one but, and i'm going to be a boring parrot here... the font is too fancy. by the time i've tried to read it i've lost interest. Just needs a little tone down thats all. But I do really like the second design

Unfortunately I agree. I think they all look 'homeade' I would stick with something cleaner.

I agree with meganecp... but if i have to pick one.. would be #2 because is the only one where there is some balance with the image and the font.
Oh... and i would change that fonto too.

thanks for the comments! I have never been a Script font fan for much of anything, but she was stuck on keeping it. We ended up going with the font layout on #1 over the tree image in #3. She really liked both #2 and #3 images.
I colored in a lot of the center section of the tree whcih cleaned it up a little. This was my first sale and she likes it. Not my favorite design I've made, but the customers happy.

And that's all you can ask, well done mate.

if you live anywhere near or around pechtree city you have my coplete and total pity
i like 3 the best jsut for prefrence
but 2 really gets the idea of peachtree city across, almost perfectly