Yes but the other thread only died a little while ago, opinions dont change THAT fast

Possibly.
Also as others have said, what is the point of asking what others prefer? if everyone says the 24-70 does that mean the OP will follow their lead like a lemming?
Don't ask me. Ask OP.
Both lenses are great, but what one person raves about another thinks is nothing special.
Very true! 
24-70 F/2.8 L


