Canon 18-200 IS vs 200 f2.8L comparison photos

http://forums.dpreview​.com …rum=1029&messag​e=29734262

thedigitalpicture.com has this already

...so i'm off the hook.

http://www.the-digital-picture.com …omp=0&FLIComp=6​&APIComp=0

their full lens review is not up yet but this comparison is.

I don't get it, what are you getting at. That at f5.6 it's equal to the 70-200 at f2.8?

not at all: you can select whatever comparison you want. i have no bias whatsoever, just thought i'd help out.

"...this exercise is not very scientific and is my first attempt at any test (or sharing for that matter) so i apologize in advance for any shortcomings."

Just a thought but it might help if you put both of the comparison photos togather.

silverwolf wrote in post #6530342
Just a thought but it might help if you put both of the comparison photos togather.

of course i thought of that but i did not want to crop in the center if someone wants to see the full image, etc, figured you guys could download the untouched images and compare them however you wanted.

Oh i see thats cool then:p

delete