Foodguy wrote in post #15299205
It was posted to show how these kinds of images are made. Everything was planned, and everything was intentional.
In that case, could you could explain your reasoning with regard to these points?
The left side of the rim is edge with black, presumably from the negative fill card positioned above the glass. If this was a desired effect, why wasn't the entire rim edged in the same manner? And why wasn't such an effect used on the sides of the glass to give some separation from the white background?
What was your thinking with positioning and lighting the strawberry as you have? it doesn't look particularly fresh or appetising and seems to be lurking in the shade. Would you not have preferred this to be lit more evenly, like the edge of the glass below?
Why is there such an uneven shadow lurking in the liquid itself, given the intensity of the light from behind? What is this supposed to show the viewer? To me, it feels like there's something lurking behind the glass, almost as if it was shot in situ and then everything else was edited out in post.
And what is going on with the base of the glass? What made you choose to stand it on the material you did instead of on a lightbox or something similar? You've got all this light spilling through the bottom of the 'stem' of the glass, yet the base shows you the surface it was sat upon.