D3 Football

Three photos from a D3 FB game. Canon 40D, 300mm, f/2.8, 1.4x TC. C & C please.
1.

all nice, but a bit over saturated. #3 is really nice.

wow.. very nice.

Good captures, bad post pros. Did you use noise reduction on these?

Dan-o wrote in post #6778819
Good captures, bad post pros. Did you use noise reduction on these?

I did one default "swipe" w/noise reduction (Noiseware Professional Software). What would you suggest? And/or what pp would you suggest? Any? None? I need to know. Dependent on to where the photo is directed, I assume.

Thank (all of) you for the critique(s). This is what I want/need.

I wouldn't do the "default" swipe because if you look at your images, they are over-softened due to NR.

Since you shot at ISO 400, there is no reason to run NR - so either do it manually or just skip NR.

post one without any PP and we can go from there.

Here is the original of photo #2, "as is", that is as taken. etc.

Original Photo

Nice as is.

Yes, please use noise reduction as a last ditch step... don't do it because everyone around here keeps talking about it. It is a tool to be used in moderation and subtly.

fix your horizons and make them straight... i like the last one you posted but I dont like the pp done.... it looks like it is too saturated and such. but nice timing none the less...

I would try to be more conscious of the suns position to avoid harsh shadows across your players. Either pick the sun behind you or directly ahead of you shooting back lit.

excellent crisp shots.

Thank you all for your critiques, it is much appreciated!

i like the original #2 a lot.