momentz wrote in post #10912221
Ahh but technically they are photos. It doesn't matter what is done in post. As a professional photographer in 2010 you need to demonstrate not only your ability to use a camera, but to demonstrate a high level of proficiency with the tools used in the modern workflow, in order to set yourself apart from Joe blogs with deep pockets, all the gear, and a photography hobby
Well put! I totally agree! I for one love getting creative in Photoshop as much as I do during a shoot, I usually have the image in my head before I take the shot and know how much processing it will need, sometimes its very heavy. I don't care what I get labelled, I don't see a need to label me at all, as long as I am having fun and creating imagery that I am happy with and if others like it then bonus! I'll use whatever tools will get the job done. I use atrificial lighting... is this wrong? I once used a smoke machine to get artificial smoke on a set.. is this wrong? Photoshop is simply another tool I have at my disposal to the desired effect I want.
Moppie wrote in post #10912251
BS.

Some of the entries are clearly composites of several different photos, plus textures, all of which have been heavily adjusted and manipulated. They rely on contrasts of shape and form and most lack any of the detail or light recording normally associated with photography.
While photographs may make up the basis of the work, the work itself is graphic, not photographic in nature.
And obviously what the 'client' wanted.
weka2000 wrote in post #10912556
2 exposures blended as per most of my landscapes.
Bahahaha - sorry, I think this is a little funny Tony, you often are one of the strong voices in the 'Purest/elitest' camp
harroz wrote in post #10916414
This does beg the question then. Does the image have to be edited by the photographer? also is a commercial image one that has to have been commissioned by a commercial client?
Just wondering on the rules.
Nice thoughts... I'd say a commercial image should have to have been commissioned by a client or used commercially.
I know a huge % of big shot photogs don't do their own editing, they are way too busy drinking flash coffees that we can't pronounce to be using a computer 