Peace

First one has quite heavy vignetting, and dust spot to the right?

I like the second.Maybe cropping out some of the foreground will bring the Mom and child to be the clearer subjects?

Three is a lovely silhouette.

1. Looks over sharpened to me (or possibly the underlying jpeg is really compressed creating artifacts?)
2. The tree dominates the picture but overall I think you get away with it...I like it.
3. Best of the three. I wish the sky had more detail though...the orange seems to have drowned out anything that was there.

Second one is my favorite.

thanks everyone, yes the first one was a miss and I didn't even notice the dirty sensor.

Second shot is my favorite of the lot I actually like the foreground and agree the tree works.

Third I take shots like that all the time, there is no detail at the sky because it's break of dawn..but I find it cool take these shots every year at about this time.