Replacement of the kit lens: Sigma 18-50/2.8 or Tamron 17-35 ???

Hello Everybody.

I have a 300D with theses lenses:
18-55 3.5/5.6 Lens kit
Tamron 28-75/2.8 (which I like a lot)
Sigma 70-300 3.5/5.6 APO MAcro II

I felt in love with my Tamron but 28mm isn't very wide and when I take back the 18-55 I find the picture very soft and not very sharp.

I can't buy me a 17-40L /4 which is too expensive for me in Europe.

What lens do you tell me to buy in replacement of the 18-55 ?

My first opinion was to buy the Tamron (who seems to be sharp) but the new Sigma 18-50/2.8 EX DC seems to be a great competitor !!!

Can you help me in my choice ?

Thanks in advance.

Yves

Yves,

welcome to the forum

I also have the 18-55 and the Tamron 28-75/2.8, and I agree with you.
Still, I find the 18-55 usable at f/8 ... not stellar, but usable.

Other options might include
- the Canon EF 15/2.8 Fisheye
- the Tokina 17/3.5 AT-X Pro
- the (older) Canon 20-35/2.8 L (going on eBay now and then in the 400-450$ range)
- The manual focus MC Zenitar 16 mm fisheye with M42 adapter (150$ new)

And ... last but certainly not least ... bear in mind that at www.canonextrapromotio​n.com you can get a 100 EUR cashback voucher for the 17-40/4.0 ... if you are not living in one of the European countries that are excluded, like Italy or Denmark.

Best regards,
Andy

Thanks a lot Andy for your fast response.

I have seen the extrapromotion for the 17-40L. The problem is that it's a 400 Euro more expensive (with the promotion) more than the Tamron and 300Euros more than the Sigma....

And I can't negociate this price with my wife.... ()


I have look for the 20/35 2.8L which is in my price (in the 400-450$ range) but I can't find any of these... The only one has a level price of 649 Euros...
Best regards.

Yves

Maybe this one: http://cgi.ebay.fr …7797&rd=1&ssPag​eName=WD2V

I heard some good things about the Tamron 17-35/2.8, e.g. here ... just a small mention.
Haven't used it, but my Tamron 28-75/2.8 is a great lens.
I know, this doesn't say much, but it might be worth the try.

Best regards,
Andy

I have to say that I think the 18-55 has gotten a bad rap. No one really has any reviews on it, but most people say it's a junk lens. Pesonally, I think it is a better bargain than the niffty fify. My copy seems to be sharp wide open, from edge to edge. The build quality isn't the greatest, but it is pretty darn sharp. I just took this picture a few minutes ago of a book. It was shot at 50mm 5.6 at a 50th of a sec with widow light. And it really focuses close. Looks sharp to me. This was hand held too.

HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.

I've been looking at the 18-50 2.8 Sigma as well. FM has some reviews on it and most of them are positive. I've also been looking at the 24-60 2.8 Sigma, but I can't really find much in the way of opinions on it. If you get the 18-50, let us know how it is.

I bought one of the first copies of the 18-50 f2.8. I am well pleased. I'm now gravitating to primes and it is the only zoom I still use regularly. My only complaint is it is not HSM and the focusing ring seems to be just where I hold the lens. I'm afraid someday I'll be gripping it too tightly as it focuses and I'll strip a gear or something. It seems well made and the zoom and focus are very smooth. Images are sharp with good contrast.

Cactus, is that a 100% crop?

I see the text getting blurry towards the corners.

I own both the kit lense and Tamron 28-75 and the Tamron just spanks it.

http://etischer.com/30​0d/Tamron28-75.html

Review with corner 100% crops (where most lenses are weak) of some lenses (dont bother looking at the 70-200 F4...he seems to have screwed that one up)

Andythaler wrote:
Maybe this one: http://cgi.ebay.fr …7797&rd=1&ssPag​eName=WD2V

This one has a low limit price of 550 Euro
And I think the price will rise more....

Thanks Andy for the link.
The Tamron seems to be the Choice...

Yffic

I think the ef-s 18-55mm is okay sharp for the price, i don't understand all the talk about it being a crap lens. People should remember the price paid for this Lens.

It's actually fair up-close. This was taken handheld in low light (overcast weather):
EF-S 18-55mm
Sprucetree@ f/5.6 (Warning - large file)

Cheers
Kristian

There is no low limit price on European eBay, as far as I know.
You are right, maybe it will rise more (you never know at eBay until the very last second )

Best regards,
Andy