Talaska wrote in post #9070374
Hey its all in what you believe, and please don't try to put someone else down for what they believe in. I don't know how you can compare PORTRAIT PHOTOGRAPHY to wildlife photography, but I suppose you could go to some nude beaches and sit in the bushes and take photos if you want. There is a reward feeling you get taking a walk in the woods looking for wildlife, sitting quietly on the side of a lake photographing ducks and birds, or climbing 1000 foot up the side of the mountain to photograph some sheep and you get home and find out you had some nice photo's that day. All I had said was if shooting at a zoo, or game farm, or wildlife refuge just post that is where the photos were taken. Many people do list that these were taken at the zoo.
Hey, I didn't put anybody down! In fact I stated repeatedly that it's up to each individual photographer's own feelings/discretion etc. Don't put words in my mouth.
As far as "comparing" PORTRAIT PHOTOGRAPHY to using Wildlife Models, I was sort of being facetious if you couldn't tell. But also a bit serious, as they are, if you break it all down to the bare bones, the same thing...you PAY a model to pose, the same way a person would pay a wildlife model.
If someone is opposed to it, fine, that's their prerogative or opinion. I respect that.
Yes I agree, it is REWARDING to be able to take a walk in the woods, climb a mountain etc, and find a subject(s) and take some wonderful images etc, but not everyone has either the time, physical abilities, or the resources to do this, esp if they DEFINITELY want or need photos of a certain species, and may have spent a sum of money to travel to a destination in search of their subject, but with no guarantee that they'll see it, let alone capture any quality images.
I do agree that pics taken under "controlled" conditions should be acknowledged as such if appropriate.
Also, if said photos are used by a publication or for advertising purposes, or a postcard, calendar etc, it's up to the publisher's discretion whether or not they reveal where or how the photographs were achieved.
I apologize if I offended you, or anyone with my posts, or if I misinterpreted what you wrote.
It's all cool.