Discussions like this are very difficult to keep on track if for no other reason than they're about laws (good, bad and indifferent) and those laws comes from politicians.
I think it's a natural thing to want to try and understand the intent behind certain rules and restrictions. Unfortunately, it's nearly impossible to be against a rule, restriction or law without also disagreeing with the politics of those who make them. Don't think I've ever seen a post that read "You know, I love Mayor Johnson but his policies stink..." 
And thus begins the dreaded "slippery slope." 