My 1st post: Last 2009 sunsets

Please let me know which one you like most and why.
Also let me know which one didn't work for you, and why.

All shots taken with Canon EOS 50D & 24mm f/2.8 lens.
Post process: Stock on #1 & #3, Crop on #2, Saturate on #4

Happy holidays to you all!

1.

great shots, try to put those urls between

Content warning: NOT AN IMAGE

You need to post larger images. Try using "Save For Web" to keep the pixels up and the file space down.

Thanks - updated with [IMG] and larger size.

For me the lampposts bother me. I would have moved to end of the dock and left them out. I just think they are too distracting. I like the shot with just the water the best. I think it has the most to offer. But nice effort all around.

no questions #1

#1 works best for me, but I would probably like it better if you would have used the rule of 3rds and not framed it so perfect...but that's just me

Where is this?

One would be the shot that appeals most to me... compositionally it just works better for me. I think I'd like the dock a little more to the left, but still nice shot.