85mm 1.2 L & 85mm 1.2 L II

What is the real big difference between the two if someone could answer ?

Thanks

Eiro wrote in post #9630344
What is the real big difference between the two if someone could answer ?

Thanks

IIRC, the MKII has faster AF and marginally improved optics.

The II has better flare control and micro-contrast, because of it's coating. It's also about twice as fast at focusing than the I version, although, even that is still woefully slow compared to normal lenses.

Other than that, most would say they are pretty much identical when it comes to image quality. So, if price is an issue, the I version should be a good option if you need a specialty lenses such as this.

Todd Lambert wrote in post #9630361
The II has better flare control and micro-contrast, because of it's coating. It's also about twice as fast at focusing than the I version, although, even that is still woefully slow compared to normal lenses.

Other than that, most would say they are pretty much identical when it comes to image quality. So, if price is an issue, the I version should be a good option if you need a specialty lenses such as this.

"Need" not at the moment , "want" yes. I found a really good deal on one (MK I) in LA last week. ~thinking about it~, next time I'm there, maybe I'll get it. Its priced out just right IMO.

just get the I, the version two is like 1-2 sec faster in focus. Not worth it

DoomMan wrote in post #9630473
just get the I, the version two is like 1-2 sec faster in focus. Not worth it

price sticker on the I is $1,200 that I found. What do you think ?

Eiro wrote in post #9630574
price sticker on the I is $1,200 that I found. What do you think ?

pretty good price. But if you wait you might be able to snag one for 1,050-1100.

Eiro wrote in post #9630574
price sticker on the I is $1,200 that I found. What do you think ?

I have the I and never considered the II. The price difference was not worth the "upgrade". They both focus slow and both produce unbelievable results. For $1,200 I'd get it and if the urge stikes to get the II, you won't be out any money. Just make sure it's in good condition.

This page might help you:
http://www.wlcastleman​.com/equip/reviews/85m​m/index.htm

alainvd wrote in post #9632496
This page might help you:
http://www.wlcastleman​.com/equip/reviews/85m​m/index.htm

that was very useful.

I have the original 85L and have no reason to upgrade. I bought it used for around $1000 (part of it was a trade). Sure the AF speed would be nice, but I can't justify the cost on that (I shoot weddings). The funny thing is I really like the lens flare on the original 85L, in the correct backlit situation in bleeds light into the frame in a way that I find perfect for weddings.