Im for the B&W Rob
I like this kind of processing so will go for this one, Rob.
I think they all have merit Rob, but pushed for a decision I would vote no. 1 - but I would have to crop that right hand side it's a little distracting...

Thanks for the input guys - I have got a lot of cropping and retouching to do yet, didnt want to get too carried away before i knew what processing would be applied
Rob, looks like you got some nice comments when you posted those shots in the People section. And got some good advice as well. Good work there!
Yes i did - thanks for urging me to post over there Pete 
This one for me. Care to share? i love it
Its a split tone using a cyan in the highlights and a tan in the shadows. about 1 stop over exposed in lightroom and then dialed back with recovery to get the look i wanted.
Number 1 for me, though it looks like there's something wrong with her right leg from the mottling on the calf which is accentuated by the B&W conversion.
I think thats just from where she is cold - we were outside and it was very windy!
I think i will go with #1 as the style then - many thanks for your help guys!






