Marubozo, thanks for the explanation. I can see your point regarding the 28mm and that is EXACTLY where I noticed the difference of the 17-55 and the Kit Lens. Subjects on the horizon with the kit lens were smeared into the background (specially in the edges of the frame) while perfectly crisp on the theoretically better glass. There's one line I thought I'd mention: "take the same lens outside and shoot a landscape at f/10"... I have read a good deal on the 28mm and, at 1.8 it produces halos and glows which reduce resolution. At 2.8 you are more or less safe on that department, and the sweet spot of the lens is, believe it or not, at f4 ~ f5.6. At f10 you are, according to most tables, already limited by diffraction! So, f8 should be the highest for sharpness testing procedures. Of course, edge rendition of a wide angle can not be compared to edge rendition on a telephoto, so don't judge him to harshly, telephoto lenses are easier to design, and, amongst the brands, Canon is the best on telephotos and not so hot on the wide angles, so... as you said, apples to oranges
. Here's Ken Rockwells take on it: http://www.kenrockwell.com …es/28mm-f18-sharpness.htm
, and http://www.kenrockwell.com/canon/lenses/28mm-f18.htm
WARAT, I need to get one of those rocket blowers. I like the mixed lighting with white reflections on front a warm lighting to the side. Perhaps I would have liked something to anchor the object to the ground (a reflection?) so it wouldn't seem like floating in the air. Though, since its a rocket...
. Also, yes the 70-200 f2.8 was discontinued in favor of the 2.8MII. The good news is that, since people NEEED!!! to have the latest and sharpest, they are selling the MIs to buy the MIIs. Just 2 days ago one was sold at $1150! Amazing price (of course was 'robbed' from the hands of the seller in few seconds!), but you can get them from $1300~$1500 in the Sell forum and they pop out quite frequently. Now, you can't go wrong witha any of the 70-200L lenses. Some of us have the most basic f4 non-IS and are extremely happy with them, so, anything higher in the ladder is a plus on a great lens.
Trugga, I really like you last dominoe picture... the aging box is fantastic and you have done it a great service by not upping the contrast, ruining the image! Great shot.
Norbi, I believe no one is going to give anything but praise to the images you have posted, as they are exquisite. The mix between cool blue sky and warm artificial light is fantastic. The first shot with the star shapped lights of the smaller aperture is a dreamy scene. And your last water dropplet is astounding. I love the lighting and that single star glow on the left of the sphere is the cherry of the cake. Fantastic capture!!
Best regards,
Rafa.