Contest #29: Voting! (CLOSED)

First.. these are great shots!!

my first vote went for #4, for obvious reasons..
it is a very professional looking shot of a really cool item. I'd buy one.. but I already have one..

second vote goes for #24, which is really one of the best shots here. great spalsh!!

third vote goes for #3.. again... for obvious reasons.
(I did a shot like this a long time ago, too... but it didn't look this good.)

.. Lee

First off, I just came across this site a week or so ago. It's a really cool site.

Now, on to my thoughts. My favorite is number 3. While I feel the sunset (rise?) could have been stronger, the image made me want to be sitting there drinking the beer. It also has strong composition. My second and third favorites are almost ties, but I'll give the slight edge to number 17. Color, compostition, and brand identity are all strong. Number 20 is also an excellent photo, but I ranked it third because its brand identity was less strong.

As a note, my favorite image was number 23. I love the color, lighting, and mood; I just didn't think it was as strong of an advertisement as the others.

Thanks for taking the time to comment everyone. Seeing the reasoning behind people's votes is really useful. Anyway, stay tuned because the next contest is going to be different from our usual fayre. I'll post details this evening.

New contest up and running!

https://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthre​ad.php?t=94234

My votes go to:
# 04 because it is such a perfect product shot. Also, the skull in the top right of the screen adds a little subversion to the otherwise beautiful shot.

# 18 - I just love the classic look

# 1 because its a great idea well executed.

I'd also like to give an honerable mention to #24 which I very nearly voted for. I don't want to know how many takes it needed to get right!

Ok, if I'm allowed to express my admiration for a photo it would be # 16: Fairlady Z. Wish the photographer stood on a chair or something to get rid of the busy background. Imagine the car with these tiles and lighting only? Nissan would probably buy that photo.

My choices, in no particular order...

#24 because it looks like an advertisement, and the timing to get such a shot as that.

#26 for the warm colors and classic craftsmanship

#3 because it, too, looks like an advertisement, and I like the glow of the sunlight in the glass' contents.

If I could have voted for a fourth photo, it would have been #4.

-- John

Some really nice photos folks.....I only voted for 1 which was 24......If I had of been on the ball I would have voted for 26 and 2 as well, Very nice photo's,well done

Voting closes tomorrow, Monday

Yeah well not to go with the masses I gotta say #24 gets my vote.. It's just one of those hard to get moments and looks like it's been ripped straight out of a magazine.

Voting closed!

See this thread for the results
https://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthre​ad.php?t=95364